Blue Buffalo and Iams are two prominent names in the dog food industry, each with its distinct approach to canine nutrition. In this article, we delve into a comprehensive comparison of the two, examining their ingredients, quality, protein content, pricing, and recall history to provide an insightful perspective for pet owners.

Blue Buffalo Vs. Iams: An In-Depth Ingredient Comparison

Blue Buffalo Ingredients Pros:

  1. Whole Protein Sources: One of Blue Buffalo’s strengths is its commitment to using whole meat sources as the primary ingredient in most of their formulas. This often means deboned chicken, fish, or lamb, which offers dogs a high-quality, easily digestible source of protein.
  2. LifeSource Bits: Exclusive to Blue Buffalo, these are cold-formed bits interspersed with the kibble. They contain a blend of vitamins, minerals, and antioxidants designed to enhance a dog’s overall health and immune response.
  3. Natural Ingredients: Blue Buffalo prides itself on its natural approach. This means no artificial flavors, preservatives, or colors. Instead, they rely on natural preservatives like tocopherols.
  4. Grain-Free Options: For dogs with grain sensitivities or allergies, Blue Buffalo offers grain-free formulas, focusing on alternative carbohydrate sources like potatoes and peas.

Blue Buffalo Ingredients  Cons:

  1. Price Point: High-quality ingredients often come with a higher price tag. Some pet owners might find Blue Buffalo’s prices a bit steep compared to more basic dog foods.
  2. Inconsistency in Ingredient Sourcing: Although the company prioritizes high-quality ingredients, there have been instances in the past where ingredient sourcing led to recalls.

Lams Ingredients Pros:

  1. Tailored Nutrition: Iams crafts its formulas with specific nutritional needs in mind. This can be based on breed size, age, or health concerns like weight management. The brand’s ProActive Health line, for instance, is designed with ingredients to boost immunity and maintain muscle.
  2. Blend of Protein Sources: Iams uses a blend of whole meats and meat meals. Meat meals, like chicken meal or lamb meal, are concentrated protein sources. This can be beneficial for delivering a higher protein content in a smaller volume of food.
  3. Inclusion of Beneficial Grains: Not all grains are problematic for dogs. Iams includes grains like corn and sorghum, which can be easily digestible sources of energy for many dogs. They also include fibers and prebiotics for digestive health.
  4. Affordability: Generally, Iams is priced more affordably than Blue Buffalo, making it more accessible for a broader range of pet owners.

Lams Ingredients Cons:

  1. Use of By-Products: Some Iams formulas incorporate meat by-products, which are the parts of the animal left over after the primary cuts are taken. While these can still be nutritious, they’re often considered a lower quality ingredient compared to whole meats.
  2. Potential for Allergens: While many dogs digest grains like corn and sorghum without issue, others may be allergic or intolerant. The inclusion of such grains might not be suitable for all pets.
  3. Artificial Additives: Some Iams products have been known to contain artificial colors, which don’t contribute to the nutritional value of the food and can be a point of concern for some pet owners.

Comparative Analysis:

When it comes to the protein content and quality, both brands offer products that can cater to a dog’s needs. Blue Buffalo’s focus on whole protein sources ensures that dogs are getting easily digestible and high-quality meat. Iams, while incorporating meat meals, can provide a condensed source of protein, which can be beneficial for certain nutritional requirements.

The approach to grains is notably different between the two. Blue Buffalo offers both grain-containing and grain-free options, catering to a wider range of dietary needs. Iams, with its inclusion of specific grains, can offer energy and fiber but might not be the best choice for dogs with grain sensitivities.

In terms of additives, Blue Buffalo’s commitment to natural ingredients stands out. Iams, while delivering on tailored nutrition, does incorporate artificial colors in some formulas.

Price-wise, Iams generally comes out as more budget-friendly, but the cost can reflect the quality and sourcing of ingredients. Blue Buffalo, being on the pricier side, emphasizes natural ingredients and whole protein sources.

In conclusion, the choice between Blue Buffalo and Iams will largely depend on an individual dog’s needs and the preferences of the pet owner. Both brands have their strengths, and understanding the ingredient list is crucial to making an informed decision.

Compare Pricing & Discounts: Blue Buffalo vs Iams

Iams 35% Off 1st Autoship See Current Pricing & Deals
Blue Buffalo 35% Off 1st Autoship See Current Pricing & Deals

Recalls & Lawsuits: Blue Buffalo Vs. Iams

Recalls and legal actions can be indicative of a brand’s commitment to quality and safety. Let’s explore the recall histories and major lawsuits faced by Blue Buffalo and Iams to offer a clearer picture of their track records.

Blue Buffalo Recalls & Lawsuits:

  1. 2017: Blue Buffalo recalled a single lot of its Blue Wilderness Rocky Mountain Recipe Red Meat Dinner Wet Food for Adult Dogs. The concern here was the elevated levels of beef thyroid hormones, which could have led to symptoms like increased thirst and urination, weight loss, and increased heart rate in dogs.
  2. 2016: The brand had a voluntary recall of some batches of their Life Protection Formula Fish and Sweet Potato Recipe for Dogs due to potential mold presence.
  3. 2015: Blue Buffalo made headlines with a sizable recall due to a mix-up at one of their ingredient suppliers. This resulted in certain products having heightened levels of Vitamin D, leading to potential health risks for dogs.
  4. Earlier recalls also dotted Blue Buffalo’s record. The most notable was in 2007 when melamine contamination became a concern. This was part of a wider recall that affected several pet food brands.

Lams Recalls & Lawsuits:

  1. 2013: Procter & Gamble, then the parent company of Iams, initiated a recall for specific lots of its dry dog foods. The reason cited was potential salmonella contamination. The recall was more of a preventive measure, and no illnesses were reported.
  2. 2012: Iams Shakeables Turkey and Lamb Dog Treats were recalled due to potential mold growth.
  3. 2010: There was a significant recall concerning Iams cat food for low levels of thiamine (Vitamin B1). While this particular recall didn’t pertain to dog food, it did raise concerns among pet owners about the brand’s quality assurance processes.
  4. 2007: Just like Blue Buffalo, Iams was also affected by the widespread melamine contamination recall.

Lams Recalls & Lawsuits:

Blue Buffalo faced a lawsuit in 2014, primarily centered around the brand’s claims of not using poultry by-products in their food. The litigation revealed that certain products did contain these ingredients. As a result, Blue Buffalo had to pay $32 million in a settlement to the plaintiffs. This incident led to an increased emphasis on transparency and rigorous quality checks by the company.

Iams, on the other hand, has had its share of legal tussles, though not as pronounced as Blue Buffalo. Most of the lawsuits were related to the broader issues faced by its parent company, Procter & Gamble, and not solely focused on the Iams brand. However, some minor lawsuits addressed issues like misleading marketing practices, especially concerning the “ProActive Health” tag, with plaintiffs claiming the food didn’t offer any specialized health benefits.

To summarize, both Blue Buffalo and Iams have faced recalls over the years, some due to broader industry-wide issues and others specific to the brand. While recalls can be concerning, it’s essential to note how each company responded. Recalls, if handled transparently and efficiently, can demonstrate a company’s commitment to rectifying mistakes and ensuring pet safety. On the legal front, Blue Buffalo had a significant hiccup with the 2014 lawsuit, whereas Iams had more dispersed legal challenges, most not specifically tied to the product’s quality.

Compare Pricing & Discounts: Blue Buffalo vs Iams

Iams 35% Off 1st Autoship See Current Pricing & Deals
Blue Buffalo 35% Off 1st Autoship See Current Pricing & Deals

Our Verdict – Blue Buffalo vs Iams: Who Wins?

When comparing Blue Buffalo and Iams based on protein content, ingredient quality, and recall history, distinctions emerge. Blue Buffalo often prioritizes whole protein sources, while Iams combines whole meats with meat meals for condensed protein. As for ingredient quality, Blue Buffalo emphasizes natural ingredients and offers grain-free options, whereas Iams includes a broader range of grains, potentially introducing allergens. Reflecting on recall history, both brands have faced challenges, but Blue Buffalo’s significant lawsuit in 2014 stands out. Considering these factors, we lean towards Blue Buffalo for its commitment to natural ingredients and whole protein sources. However, pet owners should weigh these findings against their pets’ unique needs and preferences.


Blue Buffalo vs. Iams: Frequently Asked Questions

  1. What is the primary difference between Blue Buffalo and Iams in terms of ingredient philosophy?
    Blue Buffalo often emphasizes its commitment to using real meat as the first ingredient and promotes a holistic approach, generally avoiding artificial preservatives, colors, and flavors. Iams, on the other hand, has a focus on tailored nutrition for different life stages and conditions, sometimes using a combination of whole meats and meat meals.
  2. Which brand offers grain-free options?
    Both brands provide grain-free options. Blue Buffalo has its “Wilderness” and “Freedom” lines, which are grain-free. Iams also offers grain-free recipes, but they may be less extensive compared to Blue Buffalo’s range.
  3. Are there recalls associated with either brand?
    Yes, both Blue Buffalo and Iams have had recalls in the past, ranging from concerns over potential salmonella contamination to elevated levels of certain vitamins. It’s essential to check recent recall histories and how each company has addressed these issues.
  4. Do either of these brands cater to specific dietary needs or health conditions?
    Yes, both brands offer solutions for specific dietary needs. Iams has formulas tailored for puppies, senior dogs, weight control, and more. Blue Buffalo similarly provides age-specific formulas and has lines such as “Basics” for dogs with food sensitivities.
  5. How do protein contents generally compare between the two brands?
    Blue Buffalo often prioritizes whole protein sources like real chicken, beef, or fish. Iams, while also using whole meats, combines these with meat meals, which are condensed protein sources. The exact protein content can vary by formula, so it’s crucial to check the label for specifics.
  6. Are Blue Buffalo and Iams suitable for all life stages?
    Both brands have products tailored for all life stages, from puppies to senior dogs. They provide specific nutrient balances to cater to the unique needs of each life stage, ensuring optimum growth, maintenance, and health.
  7. Which brand is more affordable on average?
    Generally, Iams tends to be more affordably priced than Blue Buffalo. However, prices can vary depending on the specific product line, region, and where you purchase.
  8. Do both brands offer wet food options?
    Yes, both Blue Buffalo and Iams offer wet or canned food options. They provide a range of flavors and formulations in their wet food lines to cater to different preferences and dietary needs.
  9. Are there vegetarian or vegan formulas available from either brand?
    As of now, neither Blue Buffalo nor Iams is known for offering vegetarian or vegan dog food formulas. Both brands prioritize meat-based nutrition, emphasizing its importance in a canine diet.
  10. Which brand has more flavor variety?
    While both brands offer a broad spectrum of flavors and protein sources, Blue Buffalo has a slight edge in variety, particularly with its specialized lines like “Wilderness,” which includes more exotic protein options.
  11. How do the brands fare on environmental sustainability?
    Both brands have made efforts towards sustainability, though they may not be as prominent as some newer, eco-focused brands. It’s always a good practice to check their official websites or reach out to their customer service for detailed sustainability practices.
  12. What are customers saying about the palatability of these brands?
    Palatability can be subjective, as it depends on individual dog preferences. However, both Blue Buffalo and Iams generally receive positive reviews regarding taste. If your dog is picky, you might want to try a small pack first to see which brand they prefer.
  13. Are there organic options available in either brand?
    Neither Blue Buffalo nor Iams primarily markets itself as an organic brand. While certain ingredients within their formulations might be organic, it’s essential to read the label or check their official product descriptions for clarity.
  14. Which brand offers more options for large breed dogs?
    Both brands cater to large breeds with specific formulations. Iams has its “ProActive Health Large Breed” line, while Blue Buffalo offers large breed options in its “Life Protection Formula” and other lines. Both brands address the unique nutritional needs of larger breeds.
  15. How do the brands handle potential allergens in their formulations?
    Blue Buffalo has its “Basics” line, formulated for dogs with food sensitivities, avoiding potential allergens. Iams, while offering some sensitive formulas, has a broader range of ingredients across its line-up, so it’s crucial to read labels if your dog has known allergies.

By researching and understanding each brand’s offerings and philosophies, pet owners can make more informed decisions on what’s best for their furry companions. Both Blue Buffalo and Iams bring their strengths to the table, addressing various needs in the canine community.

Compare Pricing & Discounts: Blue Buffalo vs Iams

Iams 35% Off 1st Autoship See Current Pricing & Deals
Blue Buffalo 35% Off 1st Autoship See Current Pricing & Deals

The post Blue Buffalo vs. Iams Who Wins? [2023] appeared first on