In the competitive world of pet nutrition, Blue Buffalo and Fromm stand out as two prominent dog food brands. This article delves into a direct comparison, examining their ingredients, the quality of those ingredients, protein content, overall value for the price, and their recall histories. Join us as we dissect these brands to assist pet owners in making informed feeding decisions.

Blue Buffalo Vs. Fromm: An In-Depth Ingredient Comparison

Blue Buffalo Pros:

  1. Whole Meat as Primary Ingredients: One of the most commendable aspects of Blue Buffalo is their commitment to using whole meats like chicken, beef, and fish as the primary ingredients in many of their recipes. This ensures that dogs are getting quality, animal-based protein right from the start.
  2. Inclusion of “LifeSource Bits”: These are exclusive to Blue Buffalo. They’re cold-formed bits that contain a precise blend of vitamins, minerals, and antioxidants. The cold-forming process ensures that the nutrients aren’t degraded by heat.
  3. Natural Ingredients: Blue Buffalo prides itself on using natural ingredients. They avoid artificial preservatives, colors, and flavors, which can be detrimental to a dog’s health in the long run.
  4. Grain-Free Options: For dogs with grain sensitivities or allergies, Blue Buffalo offers grain-free formulas which can be beneficial for digestion and overall health.

Blue Buffalo Cons:

  1. Use of Meal: While the brand does use whole meats, they also incorporate meat meals, like chicken meal or fish meal. Although these meals are protein-rich, they are processed and not as wholesome as whole meats.
  2. Price Point: Due to its high-quality ingredients, Blue Buffalo tends to be on the pricier side, making it less accessible to some dog owners.
  3. Recent Ingredient Changes: Over the years, some long-time users have noticed changes in the ingredients or formula, which can sometimes upset a dog’s stomach if they’ve been accustomed to the old formula.

Fromm Pros:

  1. Diverse Protein Sources: Fromm offers a range of protein sources, including duck, rabbit, and pheasant, which can be especially good for dogs with specific protein allergies or for those looking to rotate protein sources.
  2. Family-Owned: Being a family-owned company, Fromm takes extra care in ensuring the quality of its ingredients and has a personal touch in its production.
  3. Grain-Free and Grain-Inclusive Options: Fromm provides both grain-free and grain-inclusive options, catering to a wider range of canine dietary needs.
  4. No Artificial Preservatives: Fromm avoids using artificial preservatives, relying instead on natural preservatives like mixed tocopherols.

Fromm Cons:

  1. Costly: Similar to Blue Buffalo, the high quality of Fromm’s ingredients can lead to a steeper price point.
  2. Use of Potato: Some of Fromm’s grain-free recipes rely heavily on potatoes as a primary ingredient. While not inherently bad, some dogs might have difficulty digesting too much potato, and it doesn’t offer the same nutritional benefits as some other vegetables.
  3. Limited Availability: Fromm isn’t as widely available as some other commercial brands, which can be inconvenient for some dog owners.

Comparison Overview:

Both Blue Buffalo and Fromm prioritize high-quality ingredients, with a clear emphasis on providing optimal nutrition for dogs. Blue Buffalo’s LifeSource Bits offer a unique blend of essential nutrients, while Fromm’s diverse protein sources can be beneficial for rotation diets or dogs with specific allergies.

However, both brands come with a higher price tag due to their premium ingredients. They also both have certain recipes that rely on meat meals or potatoes, which, while not harmful, might not be ideal for all dogs.

Dog owners should consider their pet’s specific needs, such as any allergies or sensitivities when choosing between these brands. Consulting with a veterinarian can provide further insight into which brand might be the best fit for an individual dog’s health and well-being.


Compare Pricing & Discounts: Blue Buffalo vs Fromm

 Fromm N/A See Current Pricing & Deals
Blue Buffalo 35% Off 1st Autoship See Current Pricing & Deals

Recalls & Lawsuits: Blue Buffalo Vs. Fromm

When assessing the safety and reliability of pet food brands, examining their recall histories and any related lawsuits can be instrumental. Both Blue Buffalo and Fromm have faced recalls in the past, though the reasons and circumstances varied.

Blue Buffalo Recall & Lawsuits:

  1. 2017: Blue Buffalo voluntarily recalled one lot of their BLUE Wilderness Rocky Mountain Recipe Red Meat Dinner Wet Food for Adult Dogs. The company took this action due to potential elevated levels of beef thyroid hormones, which can cause symptoms such as increased thirst and urination, weight loss, and an increased heart rate in dogs.
  2. 2016: The company issued a voluntary recall for some batches of their Life Protection Formula Fish and Sweet Potato Recipe dog food. This was due to the possible presence of excessive moisture and mold.
  3. 2015: Blue Buffalo faced multiple recalls this year. One involved a limited number of Blue Kitty Yums cat treats due to the potential presence of propylene glycol, a substance that’s not permitted in cat food. Additionally, certain batches of chew bones were recalled because of potential salmonella contamination.
  4. 2010: The company recalled some batches of their dog food due to potential vitamin D toxicity.

Blue Buffalo Recall & Lawsuits:

  1. 2015: Blue Buffalo settled a class-action lawsuit for $32 million, following claims that the company falsely advertised the absence of poultry by-products in their food, when in fact these ingredients were present.

Fromm Recall & Lawsuits:

  1. 2016: Fromm voluntarily recalled their Gold canned dog food pates due to inadequate levels of vitamins and minerals. The company decided on this action as a precautionary measure, emphasizing that no health issues had been reported.
  2. 2015: Fromm Family Foods initiated a voluntary recall of their Fromm Pate canned dog food varieties. The concern arose due to potentially elevated levels of Vitamin D, which can be harmful if consumed in significant amounts.

Fromm Recall & Lawsuits:

As of the last available data, Fromm has not faced significant lawsuits related to their pet food products. Their brand reputation remains largely untainted in this aspect, showcasing a commitment to transparency and corrective action when necessary.

In Context:

While no pet food brand is entirely immune to recalls—given the complex supply chains and production processes involved—it’s essential to note how each company addresses these issues. Blue Buffalo has faced more frequent recalls compared to Fromm and faced a substantial lawsuit about ingredient misrepresentation. However, Blue Buffalo has been consistently transparent about these issues, initiating voluntary recalls and settling legal matters proactively.

Fromm, on the other hand, has had fewer recalls, which might suggest stricter quality controls or simply fortunate circumstances. Their recalls, however, were also addressed transparently, reinforcing the brand’s dedication to pet health and safety.

For potential consumers, it’s crucial to stay updated on recent recalls and always register products after purchase, ensuring timely notifications in case of any future recalls. Both brands have shown a commitment to pet safety, but past recalls emphasize the importance of vigilant consumer awareness.


Compare Pricing & Discounts: Blue Buffalo vs Fromm

 Fromm N/A See Current Pricing & Deals
Blue Buffalo 35% Off 1st Autoship See Current Pricing & Deals

Our Verdict – Blue Buffalo vs Fromm: Who Wins?

Comparing Blue Buffalo and Fromm Dog Foods, both brands have their strengths. Blue Buffalo emphasizes real meat as the primary ingredient and provides a broad range of recipes tailored to various needs. Fromm, a family-owned brand, focuses on premium, locally-sourced ingredients, and offers an impressive array of flavors. Analyzing protein content, both brands are competitive, providing suitable percentages for different canine needs. In terms of ingredient quality, Fromm slightly edges out with its emphasis on local sourcing and hands-on quality control. Reflecting on recall history, both brands have faced recalls in the past, though the frequency and severity can vary. Given these factors, we lean towards Fromm primarily for its ingredient quality and the brand’s long-standing commitment to nutrition. However, individual needs may vary, and consulting with a veterinarian is always advised.


Blue Buffalo vs. Fromm: Frequently Asked Questions

  1. What are the primary ingredients in Blue Buffalo and Fromm dog foods? Both Blue Buffalo and Fromm emphasize the use of high-quality, natural ingredients in their recipes. Blue Buffalo often features real meat, fish, or poultry as its primary ingredient, followed by whole grains, vegetables, and fruits. Fromm also prioritizes real meat and includes a mix of grains, vegetables, and fruits, though some of their lines are grain-free.
  2. Are these brands grain-free? Both brands offer grain-free options. Blue Buffalo has its “Freedom” and “Wilderness” lines, which are formulated without grains. Fromm offers a “Four-Star Nutritionals Grain-Free” line catering to those seeking grain-free alternatives for their pets.
  3. Do these brands cater to specific life stages or dietary needs? Yes, both Blue Buffalo and Fromm provide products tailored to different life stages, including puppy, adult, and senior. They also cater to specific dietary needs and conditions such as weight management, sensitive digestion, and food allergies.
  4. Which brand offers a broader variety of flavors or recipes? Both brands have a diverse range of flavors and recipes to ensure variety in a dog’s diet. Fromm’s Four-Star Nutritionals line, in particular, boasts a wide array of flavors from game bird to beef frittata. Blue Buffalo, on the other hand, offers different lines (Basics, Freedom, Wilderness) each with its unique set of flavors and ingredients.
  5. How do the price points of Blue Buffalo and Fromm compare? Generally, Fromm tends to be a bit pricier than Blue Buffalo. However, the exact price can vary based on the specific product line, flavor, bag size, and where you purchase it. Both brands, though, are considered premium dog foods and are priced accordingly.
  6. Where are Blue Buffalo and Fromm products manufactured? Blue Buffalo products are manufactured in the United States, with facilities in various states. Fromm is a family-owned brand, and their products are also produced in the U.S., specifically in their Wisconsin facility.
  7. What kind of quality control measures do these brands employ? Both Blue Buffalo and Fromm emphasize their commitment to quality and safety. Blue Buffalo states that they perform quality checks throughout the production process. Fromm, being a smaller family-owned business, takes pride in its hands-on approach, ensuring high-quality standards at every production level.
  8. Have either of these brands had recall issues? Like many pet food companies, both Blue Buffalo and Fromm have had recalls in the past. It’s essential to stay updated on this front and check for recent recalls. Brands often address such issues and enhance their quality control measures following recalls.
  9. What types of preservatives are used in these brands? Both Blue Buffalo and Fromm prioritize using natural preservatives like mixed tocopherols (a form of vitamin E). They avoid artificial preservatives, colors, and flavors in their recipes, emphasizing a more natural approach to dog nutrition.
  10. Do Blue Buffalo and Fromm have cat food products as well? Yes, both Blue Buffalo and Fromm produce cat food lines. They apply similar principles of high-quality ingredients, variety, and specific dietary needs to their cat food as they do with their dog food.
  11. Are these brands available internationally? While primarily catered to the U.S. market, many international pet stores and online retailers offer Blue Buffalo and Fromm products. However, availability can vary based on the region.
  12. Do either of these brands offer wet food options? Yes, both Blue Buffalo and Fromm offer wet or canned dog food options. These can be used as a primary diet, mixed with dry food, or given as a special treat.
  13. How do these brands source their ingredients? Both brands emphasize their commitment to sourcing high-quality ingredients. Blue Buffalo states that they source ingredients from trusted suppliers and ensure that no chicken or poultry by-product meals are used. Fromm also underscores its dedication to premium ingredients, often sourced from local farmers and suppliers.
  14. Is there a significant difference in the protein content between the two brands? Both brands offer products with a wide range of protein content based on the specific recipe and purpose. However, on average, both Blue Buffalo and Fromm offer competitive protein percentages suitable for various dog needs and activities.
  15. How do both brands address concerns about food allergies in dogs? Both Blue Buffalo and Fromm have products specially formulated for dogs with sensitive stomachs or food allergies. Blue Buffalo’s “Basics” line is crafted for dogs with food sensitivities, emphasizing simpler ingredient lists. Similarly, Fromm offers grain-free recipes and limited-ingredient diets to cater to dogs with specific dietary concerns.

Compare Pricing & Discounts: Blue Buffalo vs Fromm

 Fromm N/A See Current Pricing & Deals
Blue Buffalo 35% Off 1st Autoship See Current Pricing & Deals

The post Blue Buffalo vs. Fromm: Who Wins? [2023] appeared first on