Blue Buffalo and Diamond Naturals are both prominent names in the dog food industry, each with its unique offerings and loyal customer base. In this comparison, we will delve deep into the aspects of ingredients, quality of those ingredients, protein content, the value proposition in terms of pricing, and the brands’ histories regarding recalls. Making an informed choice between these two brands will be easier once these critical areas are dissected.

Blue Buffalo Vs. Diamond Naturals: An In-Depth Ingredient Comparison

Blue Buffalo Ingredients Pros:

  1. Whole Meat as Primary Ingredient: Blue Buffalo often lists real meat (like deboned chicken, lamb, or fish) as the primary ingredient, ensuring that the protein source is of high quality and beneficial for dogs.
  2. LifeSource Bits: A unique feature of Blue Buffalo products is the inclusion of “LifeSource Bits.” These are kibble pieces loaded with antioxidants, vitamins, and minerals, which are cold-formed to retain their nutritional potency.
  3. Natural Dietary Supplements: Blue Buffalo incorporates beneficial supplements such as glucosamine and omega fatty acids. These promote joint health and a shiny coat, respectively.
  4. No Corn, Wheat, or Soy: Their recipes avoid some of the common allergens and fillers that can be problematic for some dogs.

Blue Buffalo Ingredients Cons:

  1. Price Point: The emphasis on high-quality ingredients often means that Blue Buffalo comes in at a higher price point compared to some other brands.
  2. Variability in Formulas: While they have a wide range of products to cater to different dog needs, this can also mean that ingredient quality varies between their product lines.

Diamond Naturals Ingredients Pros:

  1. Quality Protein Sources: Like Blue Buffalo, Diamond Naturals often leads with quality protein sources like real lamb meat, chicken, or salmon. Their grain-free formulas also include fish, providing omega fatty acids.
  2. Probiotics: Diamond Naturals dog foods contain proprietary probiotics for digestive support. This can be particularly beneficial for dogs with sensitive stomachs.
  3. Superfoods: Their recipes often incorporate superfoods like kale, chia seeds, pumpkin, quinoa, blueberries, and coconut. These not only provide essential nutrients but also have antioxidant properties.
  4. No Artificial Flavors, Colors, or Preservatives: This ensures the natural taste of the food and reduces the risk of potential allergens or irritants.

Diamond Naturals Ingredients Cons:

  1. Grain-Inclusive Formulas: While grains can be a valuable source of nutrients for many dogs, some of Diamond Naturals’ formulas include grains like corn and wheat, which might not be suitable for dogs with certain allergies or sensitivities.
  2. Fewer Specialized Formulas: Compared to Blue Buffalo, Diamond Naturals has fewer specialized diets, which might make it a bit challenging for pet parents with dogs having specific dietary needs.

Side-by-Side Analysis:

  1. Protein Content: Both brands prioritize high-quality protein sources, making them both an excellent choice for ensuring your dog gets sufficient protein. The difference may lie in the actual protein percentage, which can vary by specific product lines and life stages.
  2. Carbohydrates: Blue Buffalo’s avoidance of common allergens like corn, wheat, or soy may be preferable for dogs with sensitivities. On the other hand, Diamond Naturals, while having grain-free options, also offers grain-inclusive formulas which can be suitable for dogs that don’t have grain allergies and might benefit from the energy grains provide.
  3. Supplemental Additions: Blue Buffalo’s LifeSource Bits provide a unique blend of vitamins and minerals. In contrast, Diamond Naturals stands out with its proprietary probiotics and inclusion of superfoods. Depending on your dog’s needs – be it additional vitamin supplementation or digestive support – one might be more suitable than the other.
  4. Potential Allergens and Fillers: While Blue Buffalo generally avoids using potential allergens, some formulas of Diamond Naturals may contain grains. It’s essential to read the ingredient list, especially if your dog is known to have food allergies.
  5. Natural Ingredients: Both brands emphasize the use of natural ingredients and steer clear of artificial additives. This common ground is reassuring for pet parents who prioritize natural nutrition for their furry friends.

In summary, both Blue Buffalo and Diamond Naturals offer high-quality ingredients, and their pros and cons often balance each other out. The choice between them would primarily boil down to specific dog needs, any known allergies, and dietary preferences. As always, it’s advised to gradually transition between dog foods and monitor your pet for any adverse reactions.


Compare Pricing & Discounts: Blue Buffalo vs Diamond Naturals

Diamond Naturals 35% Off 1st Autoship See Current Pricing & Deals
Blue Buffalo 35% Off 1st Autoship See Current Pricing & Deals

Recalls & Lawsuits: Blue Buffalo Vs. Diamond Naturals

When evaluating the safety and reliability of pet food brands, understanding their history concerning recalls and lawsuits is vital. Both Blue Buffalo and Diamond Naturals, reputable brands in the pet food industry, have faced their share of challenges. Let’s dive into the specifics.

Blue Buffalo Recall & Lawsuits:

  • In 2007, Blue Buffalo acknowledged that some of its suppliers had mislabeled ingredients, leading to the unintentional addition of rice protein concentrate which might have contained melamine. This resulted in a recall of affected products.
  • In 2010, an excess level of Vitamin D was discovered in certain Blue Buffalo products, prompting a recall. High levels of Vitamin D can be harmful to pets if consumed in large amounts.
  • In 2015, the company issued a limited recall of one of its chew bone products due to potential salmonella contamination.
  • 2016 saw a recall of specific wet dog food products due to a potential health risk posed by aluminum contamination.
  • In 2017, a single lot of Blue Wilderness Rocky Mountain Recipe Red Meat Dinner Wet Food for Adult Dogs was recalled because of elevated beef thyroid hormone levels.

Blue Buffalo Recall & Lawsuits:

  • In 2014, Nestle Purina PetCare Company sued Blue Buffalo, alleging false advertising in Blue Buffalo’s claim of “no by-products” in its pet foods. Blue Buffalo eventually admitted to the presence of poultry by-product meal in some of its pet foods and settled the lawsuit in 2016.

Diamond Naturals Recall & Lawsuits:

  • In 2005, aflatoxin, a toxic mold byproduct, was found in a Diamond pet food product, leading to a significant recall.
  • The brand faced another substantial setback in 2012 when salmonella contamination led to a massive recall of Diamond Naturals products produced in their South Carolina facility. This recall was expanded to include multiple products and affected several states.
  • In 2013, certain batches of Diamond Naturals Small Breed Adult Dog Lamb & Rice Formula were recalled due to concerns about potential salmonella contamination.

Diamond Naturals Recall & Lawsuits:

  • After the 2005 aflatoxin recall, Diamond Pet Foods was sued by pet owners who claimed their pets had been adversely affected by the tainted food. The lawsuit was settled out of court.
  • The 2012 salmonella contamination led to multiple lawsuits from pet owners whose pets had fallen ill or died due to the affected products.

Comparing the two brands, both Blue Buffalo and Diamond Naturals have had recalls in the past, with varying degrees of severity. Recalls are not uncommon in the pet food industry, as brands often prioritize the safety of pets and choose to recall products out of caution. However, it’s crucial to note how the brands handle these recalls and their transparency with the public.

Blue Buffalo’s recalls ranged from potential mold contamination to elevated levels of certain ingredients. Their lawsuit with Nestle Purina highlighted the importance of accurate labeling and transparency in marketing claims.

On the other hand, Diamond Naturals had two major incidents, with aflatoxin and salmonella, which led to considerable recalls. Their responsiveness during these times, coupled with their effort to enhance quality control measures, showcased their commitment to safety.

While both brands have faced their challenges, they have also taken steps to rectify issues and enhance their product safety standards. As with all pet products, it’s essential for pet owners to stay updated on potential recalls and ensure that they provide the safest options for their pets. It’s always advised to monitor pets for any signs of adverse reactions when introducing new foods and consult with a veterinarian if any concerns arise.


Compare Pricing & Discounts: Blue Buffalo vs Diamond Naturals

Diamond Naturals 35% Off 1st Autoship See Current Pricing & Deals
Blue Buffalo 35% Off 1st Autoship See Current Pricing & Deals


Our Verdict – Blue Buffalo vs Diamond Naturals: Who Wins?

When comparing Blue Buffalo and Diamond Naturals dog foods, several factors come into play. Analyzing protein content, both brands offer high-quality sources, but Blue Buffalo often provides a slightly higher protein percentage in their core recipes. In terms of ingredient quality, Blue Buffalo tends to use more natural ingredients and emphasizes its “no by-products” approach, whereas Diamond Naturals also offers real meat as the first ingredient but can be more varied in their formulations. However, concerning recall history, both brands have had recalls, with Diamond Naturals experiencing significant incidents related to aflatoxin and salmonella. Given these considerations, we lean towards Blue Buffalo for its consistent ingredient quality and slightly superior protein content, although both brands have their merits. It’s always essential to choose what aligns best with your pet’s specific needs.


Blue Buffalo vs. Diamond Naturals: Frequently Asked Questions

  1. What are the primary protein sources in Blue Buffalo and Diamond Naturals dog foods? Blue Buffalo primarily uses real meat, such as chicken, lamb, beef, or fish, as their top protein sources. Diamond Naturals also emphasizes real meat, like chicken, lamb, or fish, but may include meal versions for concentrated protein.
  2. Do either of these brands use artificial preservatives or colors? Blue Buffalo prides itself on avoiding artificial preservatives, colors, or flavors in their formulations. Diamond Naturals also steers clear of artificial additives, focusing on natural ingredients for flavor and preservation.
  3. Which brand offers grain-free options? Both Blue Buffalo and Diamond Naturals offer grain-free variants. Blue Buffalo’s Freedom and Wilderness lines are grain-free, while Diamond Naturals has specific grain-free formulas catering to various dietary needs.
  4. How are these brands priced comparatively? Diamond Naturals is typically more budget-friendly compared to Blue Buffalo, which positions itself as a premium brand. However, prices can vary depending on the specific product line and where it’s purchased.
  5. Where are these brands manufactured? Blue Buffalo products are made in the USA, with some ingredients globally sourced. Diamond Naturals is also produced in the United States, with several manufacturing plants across the country.
  6. What is the carbohydrate content in these foods? Blue Buffalo utilizes various carbs like brown rice, barley, and peas. Their grain-free lines use potatoes or tapioca. Diamond Naturals employs carbs like rice, peas, barley, or potatoes, depending on the formula.
  7. Do these brands offer diet-specific formulas, such as for weight management or senior dogs? Yes, both brands provide a wide range of specialized formulas. Blue Buffalo has specific lines like “Senior” or “Weight Control.” Diamond Naturals also offers formulations tailored to specific life stages and dietary needs.
  8. Which brand has a wider variety of flavors and recipes? While both brands offer a range of flavors and formulations, Blue Buffalo has a slightly broader array due to its multiple product lines, including Basics, Wilderness, and Freedom, each with various flavors.
  9. How do the two brands approach dietary supplements, like omega fatty acids or probiotics? Blue Buffalo integrates LifeSource Bits into most recipes – these are kibble bits rich in antioxidants, vitamins, and minerals. Diamond Naturals includes superfoods in their recipes and emphasizes omega fatty acids, antioxidants, and proprietary probiotics for digestive health.
  10. Are there options for dogs with food allergies? Absolutely. Blue Buffalo’s Basics line is crafted for dogs with food sensitivities, using limited ingredients. Diamond Naturals offers some limited ingredient diets and ensures a single protein source in those recipes.
  11. What’s the calorie content like for each brand? Calorie content can vary widely depending on the specific product and formula. However, on average, Blue Buffalo tends to be slightly more calorie-dense than Diamond Naturals. It’s essential to check the specific product details based on your dog’s caloric needs.
  12. Do the brands offer wet food options? Yes, both Blue Buffalo and Diamond Naturals have wet food offerings. Blue Buffalo’s canned food comes in various flavors and formulations, and Diamond Naturals also provides wet food options, aligning with their dry food recipes.
  13. How do the two compare in terms of consumer reviews and satisfaction? Both brands have a strong following and generally positive reviews. Blue Buffalo often gets praise for ingredient transparency and quality, while Diamond Naturals is frequently lauded for its value for money and nutritional content.
  14. Which brand is more environmentally conscious in its manufacturing or sourcing? While both brands emphasize their commitment to quality and sustainable sourcing, Blue Buffalo often highlights its use of natural ingredients and avoidance of by-products. Diamond Naturals focuses on holistic ingredients, and both brands aim for ethical sourcing, though detailed sustainability practices can vary.
  15. Have either of these brands collaborated with veterinarians for their formulas? Blue Buffalo often mentions that their recipes are vet-approved and crafted with veterinary input. Diamond Naturals also emphasizes the role of veterinarians and nutritionists in developing their recipes, ensuring they meet the dietary needs of pets.

Compare Pricing & Discounts: Blue Buffalo vs Diamond Naturals

Diamond Naturals 35% Off 1st Autoship See Current Pricing & Deals
Blue Buffalo 35% Off 1st Autoship See Current Pricing & Deals

The post Blue Buffalo vs. Diamond Naturals: Who Wins? [2023] appeared first on